| Coach | School(s) | Titles |
|---|---|---|
| Bob Hyland * | Saint Mary's Springs | 9 |
| John Hoch | Lancaster | 7 |
| Jerry Sinz | Edgar | 7 |
| Pat Rice | Waunakee | 7 |
| Cal Tackes | Stratford | 6 |
| Dave Keel | Homestead | 6 |
| Joe LaBuda | Menomonie | 5 |
| Pat Martin | Monroe | 5 |
| Steve Jones | Kimberly | 5 |
| Wayne Steffenhagen | D.C. Everest | 5 |
| Bill Young # | Catholic Memorial | 5 |
| Tom Taraska | Arrowhead | 4 |
| Ken Golomski | Ashwaubenon | 4 |
| Doug McArthur | Darlington | 4 |
| Kirk DeNoyer ^ | Wisconsin Lutheran | 4 |
| Mark Lusic | Amherst | 4 |
| * - also won 8 WISAA titles | ||
| # - also won 4 WISAA titles | ||
| ^ - also won 1 WISAA title |