| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | SCHOOL |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| Robert Holschuh (POY) | For | Sr | Pius XI |
| Bobby Kohl | For | Sr | Shorewood |
| Kevin Marx | For | Sr | New Berlin West |
| Nick Lehrer | For | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Sohan Shah | For | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Henry Cummings | Mid | Sr | Shorewood |
| Greg Borsari | Mid | Sr | Pius XI |
| Matt Putaraska | Mid | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Austin Rosenberger | Mid | Sr | Pewaukee |
| James Pierson | Mid | Jr | Brown Deer |
| Elliot Kucharzyck | Def | Sr | Shorewood |
| Jake Nevermann | Def | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Sammy Damato | Def | Sr | Pius XI |
| Andrew O'Neill | Def | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Thomas Schuerman | Def | Sr | Greendale |
| Garrett Shibilski | GK | Jr | Pewaukee |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Alex Zabel | For | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Petar Miskov | For | Jr | Whitnall |
| Aaron Wilson | For | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Dramane Berte | For | Sr | Cudahy/St. Francis |
| Evan Martin | For | Sr | Pius XI |
| Alex Surprise | Mid | Jr | Pius XI |
| Ethan Brownell | Mid | Sr | Pewaukee |
| John Fauser | Mid | So | Greendale |
| Dusan Ogjanovic | Mid | Sr | Greenfield |
| Nick Stanisic | Mid | Sr | Wauwatosa East |
| Jack Krenzien | Def | So | Wauwatosa West |
| Nick Brandt | Def | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Chris Knitter | Def | Sr | Shorewood |
| Mikey Perez | Def | Jr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Jason Czech | Def | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Cooper Lang | GK | Jr | Shorewood |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Victory Maniscalco | For | Sr | New Berlin West |
| Mark Hewett | For | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| David Castillo | For | So | Greenfield |
| Corbin Messman | Mid | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Sam Hanrahan | Mid | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Michael Schinker | Mid | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Sean Tabbert | Mid | Jr | Pius XI |
| Luis Nunez | Mid | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Bryan Domitrz | Mid | Jr | Whitnall |
| Brad Nagel | Mid | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Bennett Wiley | Mid | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Cameron Vugrinovich | Mid | Jr | Cudahy/St. Francis |
| Joe Schauer | Mid | Fr | Whitnall |
| David Franke | Mid | Sr | New Berlin West |
| Reed Albinger | Mid | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Joel Zembles | Mid | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Josh Landers | Mid | Sr | Shorewood |
| Sam Tharp-George | Mid | Jr | Shorewood |
| Zach Barnhart | Def | Sr | Whitnall |
| Gejsi Tahiraj | Def | Sr | Cudahy/St. Francis |
| Jimmy Kuhnz | Def | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Tim Rink | Def | Jr | New Berlin West |
| John Mullooly | Def | Jr | Pius XI |
| Chinedu Ozodi | Def | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Issay Valadez | Def | South Milwaukee | |
| Roberto Jimenez | Def | Jr | Cudahy/St. Francis |
| Chris Kelnhofer | Def | Jr | Whitnall |
| Ryan Hudson | Def | Jr | Brown Deer |
| Noah Ortiz | Def | Jr | Brown Deer |
| Mile Sever | Def | Fr | Greendale |
| Nick Hess | Def | So | Greendale |
| Marco Marquez | Def | Jr | Pius XI |
| Stephen Lisiecki | Def | So | Greenfield |
| Ashton Terry | GK | Sr | Pius XI |
| Brett Szalaczinski | GK | Jr | Greenfield |