| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron Horvat (MVP) | Senior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders | |
| Nick Biasiotta | MF | Senior | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| Dominic Calvano | D | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Trey Dowling | F | Senior | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| Mike Dugan | MF | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Sam Fredman | F | Junior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Patrick McNulty | MF | Senior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Zach Self | D | Junior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Nathan Skarie | MF | Senior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Connor Wall | D | Senior | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| Mac Wheeler | GK | Senior | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| James Zimmerman | D | Senior | Mukwonago Indians |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tylor Bacher | MF | Junior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Jack Balistreri | MF | Senior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Jorge Barreiro | D | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Tony Covelli | D | Junior | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| Robert Holschuh | MF | Junior | Pius XI Popes |
| Casey Jehn | D | Junior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Sean Lenz | F | Senior | Mukwonago Indians |
| Justin Loncaric | D | Senior | Pius XI Popes |
| Nick Moon | MF | Sophomore | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Mark Samuel | F | Junior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Bryan Seefeld | GK | Junior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Matt Waller | F | Senior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Bethel | G | Junior | Waukesha North Northstars |
| Greg Borsari | MF | Junior | Pius XI Popes |
| Ryan Christensen | D | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Tanner Federspill | D | Junior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Taylor Goddard | F | Sophomore | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Jack Gross | D | Senior | Pius XI Popes |
| Ben Hartzler | D | Junior | Waukesha North Northstars |
| Daniel Jacobson | G | Junior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Colin Koerber | MF | Sophomore | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Mitchell Krismer | MF | Sophomore | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Evan Martin | F | Junior | Pius XI Popes |
| Angel Meza | MF | Junior | Waukesha South Blackshirts |
| Brady Smith | G | Freshmen | Waukesha South Blackshirts |
| Brad Suchorski | D | Junior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Jonah Sutherland | D | Senior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Max Tavira | F | Junior | Waukesha South Blackshirts |
| Zach Thoreson | G | Junior | Mukwonago Indians |
| Josh Vick | F | Senior | Mukwonago Indians |