| NAME | SCHOOL | POSITION | YEAR |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| Jared Marty** | Cambridge | P | Junior |
| Trevor Syse | Belleville | P | Junior |
| Cole Denniston | Marshall | P | Junior |
| Tucker Tesdal | Cambridge | C | Junior |
| Antonio Unzeuta | Waterloo | INF | Junior |
| Thomas Hoffman | Cambridge | INF | Junior |
| Darris Schuett | New Glarus | INF | Senior |
| Cooper Usgaard | Marshall | INF | Junior |
| Cooper Dreyfus** | New Glarus | OF | Senior |
| Dawson Kalish | Marshall | OF | Senior |
| Carter Brown | Cambridge | OF | Junior |
| Gavin Boyum | Belleville | OF | Junior |
| Blake Huebner | Waterloo | Utility | Senior |
| Kylo Barker | New Glarus | DH | Senior |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Carter Siegenthaler | New Glarus | P | Junior |
| Wyatt Jennings | Marshall | P | Soph |
| Kelby Petersen | Marshall | C | Senior |
| Brody Tschanz | Waterloo | INF | Senior |
| Cooper Setz | Waterloo | INF | Soph. |
| Leyton Mihlbauer | New Glarus | INF | Frosh |
| John Holcomb | Wisconsin Heights | INF | Senior |
| Wyatt Peterson | Waterloo | OF | Senior |
| Easton Dreyfus | New Glarus | OF | Soph |
| Haiden Nolden | Marshall | OF | Junior |
| Peyton Mendleski | New Glarus | Utility | Senior |
| Marco Damiani | Cambridge | DH | Frosh |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Demarcus Connor | Belleville | P | Soph |
| Jace Horton | Cambridge | INF | Junior |
| Mason Haberkorn | Marshall | INF | Senior |
| Collin Petersen | Marshall | INF | Soph |
| Lathan Parman | Wisconsin Heights | INF | Junior |
| Cayden Kennedy | Wisconsin Heights | INF | Soph |
| Carson Syse | Belleville | INF | Junior |
| Ryan Downing | Belleville | INF | Junior |
| Owen Bernhardt | Cambridge | OF | Frosh |
| Trevor Firari | Waterlo | OF | Frosh |
| Kaden DeSmet | Belleville | OF | Soph |
| Jacob Brabender | Wisconsin Heights | oF | Soph |
| Carter Lund | Cambridge | Utility | Frosh |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | Cooper Dreyfus | New Glarus |