| NAME | SCHOOL | YEAR |
|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Noah Daniels | New Berlin West | 12 |
| Jordan Glenn | Wisconsin Lutheran | 12 |
| Ashton Janowski | Pewaukee | 12 |
| Kon Knueppel | Wisconsin Lutheran | 10 |
| Milan Momcilovic | Pewaukee | 11 |
| Josh Terrian | Pewaukee | 12 |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Jamiir Allen | Wisconsin Lutheran | 11 |
| Nick Janowski | Pewaukee | 10 |
| Jaquan Johnson | Pius XI Catholic | 10 |
| Greyson Pritzl | West Allis Central | 12 |
| Najashi Tolefree | West Allis Central | 12 |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Julian Alvarez Robles | Pius XI Catholic | 10 |
| Will Bauer | New Berlin Eisenhower | 12 |
| Ja'Quell Chisom | Pius XI Catholic | 12 |
| Courtney Davis Jr. | West Allis Central | 12 |
| Tommy Fritsch | Greendale | 11 |
| Josiah Gillie | West Allis Central | 12 |
| Alex Hernandez | Wisconsin Lutheran | 12 |
| Devin Isaj | Greendale | 9 |
| Emmett Loew | Pewaukee | 12 |
| Sam Susek | New Berlin West | 11 |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | ||
| Milan Momcilovic | Pewaukee | 11 |