| NAME | SCHOOL | POSITION | YEAR |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| Jake Ross | Wisconsin Lutheran | Pitcher | Junior |
| Adison Tevz | New Berlin Eisenhower | Pitcher | Senior |
| Greyson Zach | Pewaukee | Pitcher | Soph |
| Kayden Berenz | New Berlin Eisenhower | Catcher | Junior |
| Eddie Rynders | Wisconsin Lutheran | Infielder | Junior |
| EJ Kuster | Greendale | Infielder | Senior |
| Josh Bunyer | Pewaukee | Infielder | Senior |
| Caleb Johns | New Berlin Eisenhower | Infielder | Frosh |
| Logan Schill | Pewaukee | Outfielder | Senior |
| Logan Abramowski | Wisconsin Lutheran | Outfielder | Senior |
| Zach Denneau | Pius XI Catholic | Outfielder | Junior |
| Owen Dobberstein | Pewaukee | Utility | Soph |
| Ben Doherty | Pius XI Catholic | DP | Senior |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Jack Lentz | Greendale | Pitcher | Senior |
| Tyler Hewitt | New Berlin West | Pitcher | Senior |
| Bryce Balistreri | Pius XI Catholic | Pitcher | Junior |
| Jackson Servais | Pewaukee | Catcher | Soph |
| Jack Bauer | Greendale | Infielder | Junior |
| Jaxon Raabe | Wisconsin Lutheran | Infielder | Senior |
| Rhett Emons | West Allis Central | Infielder | Junior |
| Enrique Carmona | Pius XI Catholic | Infielder | Junior |
| Drew Dobberstein | Pewaukee | Outfielder | Soph |
| Ben Miller | New Berlin West | Outfielder | Junior |
| Myles Rewolisnki | New Berlin West | Outfielder | Senior |
| Blake Hutter | Pewaukee | Utility | Senior |
| Luke Mattes | Greendale | DP | Soph |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Ryan Sopha | Pewaukee | Pitcher | Junior |
| Drew Miler | Pius XI Catholic | Catcher | Junior |
| Nathan Hinek | New Berlin West | Infielder | Frosh |
| Cam Bueno | Greendale | Infielder | Soph |
| Jack Bretzmann | New Berlin Eisenhower | Outfielder | Soph |
| Joe Webb | West Allis Central | Utility | Soph |
| Sam Hirthe | New Berlin Eisenhower | DP | Soph |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | |||
| Eddie Rynders | Wisconsin Lutheran | Junior | |
| COACH OF THE YEAR | |||
| Steve Kargus | Wisconsin Lutheran |